Action and Reflection: Not Mutually Exclusive

“In modern times, things have been different: we take for granted that there must be an absolute divide between vital Christian experience on the one hand and careful doctrinal theology on the other. To us, action and reflection seem mutually exclusive, especially when it comes to the Christian faith. The last thing we would expect to find is gospel and theology flowing from the same passionate commitment. But in the long sweep of Christian history, that is how it has usually been, from the church fathers and the scholastics through the Reformers and Puritans. All of them recognized that simple, saving faith could and should be elaborated into the Trinitarianism of Nicaea and the incarnational theology of Chalcedon. It took the crafty liberal theologians of the nineteenth century to popularize the argument that central Christian doctrines were, in Adolf Harnack’s words, ‘a work of the Greek spirit on the soil of the gospel’ and a betrayal of the simplicity of Jesus’ message. At that time, conservative theologians disagreed. One of the great ironies of modern theological history is that the heirs of those conservatives who opposed high liberalism have become the chief bearers of the Harnackian bias against doctrine. Whenever we assume that the best way to embrace the simple gospel is to eschew the difficulties of doctrine, Evangelicals are unconsciously adopting the position of their historic opponents and standing in contradiction to their own best interests. In doing so, they take themselves out of the very stream of power that made their movement possible in the first place: the gospel stream of doctrine and devotion that flows from the church fathers to the first fundamentalists…Fidelity to the gospel requires us to recognize doctrinal content, and those who would preach the gospel must make use of the tools of theology.”

Fred Sanders, Jesus in Trinitarian Perspective

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s